Table of Contents:   

INTRODUCTION «   
ECONOMY «   
EDUCATION «   
ENVIRONMENT «   
GOVERNMENT «   
HEALTH «   
PUBLIC SAFETY «   
SOCIAL ISSUES «   
TRANSPORTATION «   
URBAN LIVABILITY «    

TRANSPORTATION:
Traffic

 



back  |  next

     

Traffic needs to be dealt with now, before it becomes a major problem.

Section Summary

Most people who mention traffic believe that it will become a major problem if proactive steps are not taken now to develop comprehensive solutions. While a number of people acknowledge that Portland’s traffic situation is better than that of other major cities, they worry that this will soon cease to be the case. Others feel that traffic has already gotten out of hand, and note a number of specific “problem areas” that need fixing in the immediate to near future. Portlanders want to minimize the amount of time spent in their cars and imagine a future in which “commuting and traveling in and out of the city is easy, safe, and uncongested—a pleasant experience.”

While Portlanders agree that traffic and long commute times reduce quality of life, there are major disagreements on how to address the city’s traffic problems. Three distinct perspectives emerge, each with workable but conflicting solutions for reducing and/or preventing traffic. However, despite these disagreements on methods, respondents concur that congestion must be addressed soon if the City is to prevent the traffic nightmares associated with other West coast cities.

Summary of Main Ideas

  1. Long commutes in cars are highly undesirable.
  2. Traffic is relatively manageable now, but will be unbearable in the future if nothing is done.
  3. Traffic is already a major problem requiring immediate City attention.
  4. In Portland, public transportation and auto traffic are inter-related.

Summary of Tensions and Disagreements

  1. How can we solve and prevent traffic problems in Portland?

MAIN IDEAS

  1. Long commutes in cars are highly undesirable.
  • Depending on where people live and work, some Portlanders feel that commute times are quite good while others complain of long (45 minute plus) commute times.
  • Portlanders agree that commute times should be kept to a minimum; many mention 20 minutes or less as the ideal commute time.
"[In 2030] lots of intelligence and money have gone into designing and maintaining the road ways, so a ten minute trip to the store does not end in road rage and a commute to work leaves you feeling like a human being at the end.”

Sample Strategies:

  1. Have employers stagger the times at which people enter and exit work.
  2. Create more affordable housing so people can live closer to their places of work.
  3. “Increase mass transit and buses to suburbs. More carpooling.”
  4. Create express bus and MAX lines to reduce the length of cross-town commutes on public transportation.
  5. Many Portlanders agree that “additional freeway lanes are needed in many areas.”

  1. Traffic is relatively manageable now, but will be unbearable in the future if nothing is done.
  • People who move to Portland from other large cities (LA, D.C., NYC., Seattle, etc..) express the opinion that traffic is better in Portland than in these other places.
  • Many respondents note that as the city becomes denser, traffic is sure to increase.
  • Respondents believe that traffic will be a major problem in the future if the City doesn’t take steps now to plan for it.
“Sure we have some traffic… but nothing like the snarls you see around ‘big cities.’ I don’t want Portland to become the next Seattle.”

“Traffic will be a huge issue in 20 years and it’s not too soon to start planning for it! Look at Seattle and how terrible their traffic is, and Portland could end up the same way. Yuck!"

Sample Strategies:

  1. Developers should be required to plan for how new traffic will be handled when they create new developments.
  2. “A focus on creating more self-sustaining neighborhoods. The reason for this is to reduce the number of people commuting into the city core for work. Living close to work is the only way to alleviate this problem.”
  3. Widen roads and freeways in anticipation of population growth in coming years.
  4. Create better incentives for people to switch from using cars to using public transportation (many ideas for incentives are mentioned in Transportation: Public Transportation).
  5. “Decrease auto traffic by increasing licensing fees, fuel tax, [and] parking fees.”

  1. Traffic is already a major problem requiring immediate City attention.
  • Many people mention that traffic has been getting progressively worse in Portland over the years. Some people feel this is a relatively recent development (in the past 5 years or so) while others feel it began ten or even fifteen years ago.
  • A number of respondents feel that traffic has reached a point where it is unmanageable, unhealthy and a major stressor in their lives.
  • People speak of witnessing acts of road rage and believe that traffic is making Portlanders less friendly and more aggressive.
  • Many respondents lament having to idle their cars in bumper-to-bumper rush-hour traffic, as this creates unnecessary pollution.
  • There are certain “chronic areas” that are consistently jammed up. Frequently mentioned problem areas included (in no particular order): downtown, I-5 from N. Lombard through the Marquam Bridge, Hwy 26 from Beaverton to Portland, I-84 and the Columbia River Crossing.
“I think the city is noticeably more difficult to navigate in the past four years. I agree with the city’s efforts to create a dense core, but more attention to traffic –cars, bikes, and pedestrians –is needed.”

“The more Portland improves, the more congested it gets. Waiting in traffic, sometimes sitting through 3 red lights to get somewhere, is a major headache.”

Sample Strategies:

  1. Improve traffic light synchronization. Many respondents cite specific intersections downtown and on the inner Eastside where traffic lights seem poorly synchronized.
  2. “Study large cities throughout the world to find methods of handling traffic ... And find best practices that could be applicable in Portland.”
  3. “More lanes on the major streets (like Powell, Division, etc.) to handle the traffic jams.”
  4. “I hope to see public transportation improved to alleviate traffic gridlock and pollution.”
  5. Increase streetcar and bus routes on the Eastside to link more people and neighborhoods to MAX lines and express bus routes.

    Downtown:

  6. Make certain parts of downtown “car-less.”
  7. Charge a vehicle toll on cars entering certain parts of downtown similar to that levied in London.
  8. Increase the use of public transit downtown by enlarging the size of Fareless Square.
  9. Decrease the use of cars downtown by creating underground parking lots near freeway exits where commuters can leave their cars and board public transit downtown.
  10. Improve the synchronization of traffic lights throughout downtown, especially during rush hour.
  11. “Discourage unnecessary driving by raising parking costs downtown and in the central core.”

    Interstate 5:
  1. Create a circular route around Portland so that North/South traffic on I-5 can bypass downtown Portland.
  2. Create an underground “through tunnel” or “express tunnel” for I-5 commuters who do not want to exit downtown.
  3. Add additional lanes to I-5 between North Lombard street and downtown Portland.
  4. Create MAX lines that go North to Vancouver and South to Wilsonville or Salem to ease traffic on I-5.
  5. Build a bullet train from Seattle to San Diego, so West Coast travelers can move quickly between all the major cities.

    Columbia River Crossing:

  1. Many people suggest building another bridge between Washington and Oregon to ease congestion between Vancouver and Portland.
  2. A number of other respondents advocate for an express MAX from Vancouver to downtown with a big park and ride lot in Vancouver.

  1. In Portland, public transportation and auto traffic are interrelated.
  • Portlanders understand (and seem frustrated by the fact that) the busses and the MAX can only move at the speed of car traffic. They fear that as long as there is auto congestion, these forms of mass transit will not be as fast as they could be, which in turn will deter riders, creating additional auto congestion.
  • Many people believed that eventually public transit in downtown would have to be moved either below or above ground to ease congestion in the inner city.
  • People also complained about bus stops that jut into the roadways and block traffic behind them. They suggest a separate lane or aisle that busses can pull into when picking up passengers.

TENSIONS AND DISAGREEMENTS

  1. How can we solve and prevent traffic problems in Portland?

    Portlanders seem to agree that traffic negatively impacts quality of life, increases stress levels and unnecessarily pollutes the environment. However, they disagree on how to address and prevent traffic problems. Opinions on this issue can be divided into three major groups, each with a roughly equal number of respondents:

    Reduce Auto Use.
    Some Portlanders believe that the only way to prevent future traffic is to deter people from using automobiles. These respondents favor “traffic calming” measures that slow or deter cars while facilitating the use of public transit, walking and cycling (e.g. tolls for entering downtown, more trollies and streetcars, bike-only lanes, “car-free” downtown).

    Improve Traffic Flow.
    An equally large number of people oppose this viewpoint, believing that the solution is not to force people out of their cars by allowing congestion to get worse. These respondents call for widened roads and freeways, better synchronization of traffic lights, separate routes for cyclists, and other measures to improve the flow of automobile traffic.

"To continue to ignore the need for streets and street improvements will lead to bad roads and slow down the traffic flow with roadblocks when we really need to smooth the autos out of the living areas of the inner city- not clog them more.”

“Quit trying to get me on a choo-choo, and get me some freeway capacity.”

Pursue Multiple Strategies.
Still others believe that both of the above solutions must be pursued simultaneously. More people must be willing to switch to public transportation and road conditions must be improved to reduce congestion for cars, as well as busses and MAX which share the same roads.

“[In 2030] most people get around by bike and transit most of the time…When you need to drive, the roads aren’t clogged.”

“[In 2030] traffic flows reasonably well through the major corridors, and there are more mass transit options. Subsidies for public transportation make riding mass transit cheaper than driving, and thus attractive to commuters who would otherwise prefer the convenience of their own vehicle.”

back  |  next


Economy | Education | Environment | Government | Health | Safety | Social Issues | Transportation | Urban Livability


   

Vision into Action / 1900 SW 4th, Suite 7100 / Portland, Oregon 97204 / Phone: (503) 823-9585