VOICES FROM THE COMMUNITY:

The visionPDX Input Report

URBAN LIVABILITY:
City Appearance

 


back  |  next

     

Community members value Portland's natural beauty and distinctive appearance.

Section Summary

In this section, community members describe the features of both the natural and built environment that contribute to creating a sense of beauty within the city. Portlanders value beauty and believe that a pleasing city appearance helps generate a strong sense of place, setting Portland apart from other American towns and cities. They disapprove of changes that make the city less attractive as well as those that make the city less unique. Looking to the future, they want Portland’s character to be maintained and its beauty enhanced and made equally accessible to all people.

While Portlanders agree that beauty is important, they disagree on the topic of cleanliness. Some people feel that cleanliness and beauty go together, while others feel that “grittiness” possess a certain charm of its own. A major debate emerges over whether or not Portland is a clean city, with some applauding Portland’s cleanliness and others expressing the opinion that Portland is becoming an increasingly dirty and unpleasant place to live.

Summary of Main Ideas

  1. Both the built and natural environments contribute to Portland's beauty.
  2. New development and redevelopment should enhance the city’s beauty.
  3. The city’s appearance directly impacts people’s lives.
  4. Everyone in Portland should have access to beauty.
  5. Portland should strive to maintain its distinctive look and feel.

Summary of Tensions and Disagreements

  1. How clean is Portland? Should we strive to be cleaner?

MAIN IDEAS

  1. Both the built and natural environments contribute to Portland's beauty.
  • Portlanders value beauty and feel that a beautiful city is one that successfully balances the natural and built environments.
  • The overwhelming majority of respondents think Portland is blessed with a beautiful natural environment, including:
    • Many mature trees of different species;
    • An abundance of plants and flowers that bloom for many months;
    • Hills and mountains (e.g. Rocky Butte, Mt. Hood, the West Hills); and
    • Rivers such as the Willamette and Columbia, along with smaller creeks that feed into these.
  • Many Portlanders also see beauty in the city’s built environment. The following features contribute to creating this sense of beauty:
    • The integration of nature into the city (people love the abundance of trees in the city, urban greenspaces, wildlife, the river running through the middle);
    • A low skyline that allows for views of hills and mountains;
    • Historic buildings and homes that are unique in style to the Pacific Northwest;
    • A mix of old and new structures, including buildings and bridges;
    • Buildings that fit in with the surrounding landscape and streetscape;
    • Well-designed public gathering spaces like Pioneer Courthouse Square;
    • Public art, including fountains, sculptures, murals and art that is unique to Portland;
    • A city scale that feels “built for humans,” with walkable blocks, buildings that aren’t too large, and a compact layout that makes it easy to get around;
    • High-quality structures made to last with quality materials (Portlanders consistently equate “cheap” and “poorly made” with “ugly”); and
    • Buildings and places (parks, plazas) with unique character that are not homogenous, “cookie cutter” or mass-produced in their feeling.
  • Looking to the future, Portlanders want to preserve and enhance the city's beauty.
“[In Portland] urban and nature got married to create a livable small city with heart.”

“It’s so extremely beautiful here…not yet a huge city, but still large enough to offer so many different kinds of enjoyment—indoor and outdoor. I’m a native Portlander, 36, and still would never dream of living elsewhere, and I have looked!”

“Portland is extremely livable…the public areas are beautiful, buildings are built and maintained in a manner that preserves the old-style feel of the Pacific Northwest, the city is vibrant and used as a place to live-work-play, public parks/fountains/walkways create a feeling of community and beauty that is accessible to everyone.”

“As long as we focus on keeping Portland beautiful and a family place to live I think it will remain a great place to be for 20 years.”

Sample Strategies:

  1. More plants, trees and urban ecology.
  2. Return streams that have been placed underground or paved over to the surface.
  3. Paint and beautify the bridges over the river.
  4. “Pick up trash whenever you see it.”
  5. Increase the number of public trash cans and recycling bins downtown.
  6. Remove 1-5 from the East Bank of the river, put it underground or route it around the eastern edge of the city.
  7. Bury the power lines, or at least the ones that interfere with mature trees. Do not ruin the look of old trees to accommodate cables or power lines.

  1. New development and redevelopment should enhance the city’s beauty.
  • Portlanders strongly believe that additions to the built environment should enhance the city’s beauty.
  • Portlanders generally oppose new construction, renovations and infill development that detract from the visual appeal of the city.
  • The following types of buildings are seen by many Portlanders as unattractive:
    • Buildings, houses or condominiums that all look the same;
    • Buildings that appear cheaply, hastily or poorly constructed;
    • Buildings whose design is bland, boring, uninspired or everyday; and
    • Buildings that look out of place with the surrounding landscape/streetscape.
  • Many Portlanders think that new development should be designed to meet the needs of various different groups, such as children, families, the disabled and neighbors, not just the needs of those paying for the development.
“The density question has left many neighborhoods having to tolerate ugly housing placed side-by-side with pretty, traditional Portland homes. We live here –in large part—because it is beautiful…Developers must be held to community standards of this special place.”

“What is wrong with beautiful buildings? When a house is built on an infill lot, it should have to look like the rest of the neighborhood.”

"More bold moves need to be made architecturally. It’s pretty bland.”

Sample Strategies:

  1. Create and uphold stricter design standards to ensure that new development is high-quality and visually attractive.
  2. “Engage visionary artists, architects, landscape artists, public park designers, etc… in all phases of housing developments, commercial buildings, etc…”

  1. The city’s appearance directly impacts people’s lives.
  • The appearance of the city’s built and natural environment impacts how people feel about the city, how they feel about their own experience and how they feel about their community.
  • People feel uplifted in certain buildings, parks and public spaces but demoralized in others.
  • Portlanders want those who shape the environment (architects, builders, landscape architects, developers, arborists and others) to consider the impact of their work on the community as a whole, not just on the users of the specific building, park or new structure.
“Make sure there are garbage cans at bus stops, and then make sure someone comes by to actually empty those garbage cans regularly. There is a LOT of trash in my neighborhood, around 15th and Killingsworth, and it really affects people’s attitudes about their community and themselves.”

“The Metro 2040 vision expects many new residents in Gateway…however; Gateway currently is set up for cars, not people… It has wide, busy arterials and 1-205, wide parking lots between stores, no greenspace and few residences… Unlike Hollywood and the Pearl District, there are no beautiful historic buildings to draw new residents to Gateway.”

“[In 2030] I’d like to think that because our city is beautiful and well cared for it inspires others to care for it.”

Sample Strategies:

  1. Find a way to provide shelter/housing for the homeless. Many people have strong negative feelings about Portland when they see people sleeping on the streets.
  2. “I’d like to see the city’s low-rent, low-rise commercial strips (such as Powell and Barbur) transformed into something else.”
  3. Improve the appearance of parks, streets and open spaces in low-income neighborhoods.

  1. Everyone in Portland should have access to beauty.
  • Portlanders believe that beauty should be enjoyed by all and not reserved for a wealthy few.
  • Many people oppose efforts to “privatize” beauty, such as limiting views of the river or mountains to those who purchase riverfront property.
  • Portlanders strongly support public art, public fountains, public parks and other efforts to ensure that all Portlanders have access to beauty.
  • There is also strong support for improving the physical appearance of blighted and low-income areas, so that Portlanders with fewer resources can still experience visually attractive surroundings.
“The river belongs to the people of Portland, not the developers.”

“The Pearl is beautiful and hip, but almost no low-income people live there anymore.”

Sample Strategies:

  1. “The city buys 50% of all billboards within its limits and commissions local artists to paint them up.”
  2. Plants more street trees, especially in lower-income neighborhoods.
  3. Whenever possible, preserve mature trees; do not cut them down to make way for younger plants.
  4. Expand pedestrian and community access to the East Bank of the Willamette River (see Urban Livability: Access).

  1. Portland should strive to maintain its distinctive look and feel.
  • Portlanders place enormous value on the city’s distinctiveness—the fact that it has a unique look, feel and history. This creates a local identity, local pride and a strong sense of place.
  • Portland is often referred to as a “jewel,” a place that is more visually attractive and more livable than many other American cities, which are characterized as “bland,” “soulless” and “concrete urban jungles.”
  • As Portland grows, it should seek to grow in ways that preserve its uniqueness.
  • The majority of respondents do not want Portland to look like “Anywhere, USA” or even like other West Coast cities like Seattle or San Francisco.
“I don’t want Portland to end up looking like the suburbs. By this I mean, cheaply built buildings with poor design that all look and feel the same.”

“I do not want to drive or walk down the street and feel that I could be anywhere in America. Portland is vibrantly unique. This vision is the force that should inspire planning and laws of the community.”

"Less gentrification in unique areas. Portland runs the risk of having every old district ‘revamped’ and turned into something that looks like every other ‘unique’ district.”

TENSIONS AND DISAGREEMENTS

  1. How clean is Portland? Should we strive to be cleaner?

    A topic of much debate in this section is cleanliness, with widely differing opinions regarding whether or not Portland is currently a clean city and whether or not Portland’s appearance would be enhanced by becoming cleaner in the future.

    Many view the city as extremely clean, especially when compared to other American cities. These Portlanders praise the clean parks, streets and environment and some say Portland is the cleanest city in which they have ever lived. These respondents see cleanliness as a component of beauty, believing that Portland is a beautiful city in part because it is clean.

    Another large group of respondents also values cleanliness, but feels that Portland is becoming increasingly dirty, especially downtown. They mention feeling “frustrated,” “annoyed” and even “disgusted” by the amount of garbage they see downtown. Many attribute the dirty, garbage-strews streets to the high number of homeless people, drug addicts and “street kids” living downtown.

“Downtown Portland is unsightly and irritating. Between the torn-up streets, panhandlers, street kids, indigents, graffiti, dirty sidewalks and unkept landscaping, it’s not enjoyable. My out-of-state residents were shocked when the recently visited, at how bad it looks, sounds, and smells.”

Most people who feel that Portland is becoming too dirty would like to see the City take action to reverse this trend (many feel that Portland used to be much cleaner). They believe that with increased cleanliness, Portland will be an even more beautiful city.

“I would clean up downtown and the transit system. It is currently a blight and not a good showcase for our beautiful city. From homeless to street youth to mentally unstable, there needs to be a way to help those in need and make the downtown more welcoming for its visitors, dwellers, and daily workers.”

However, of the larger group that sees Portland as dirty, a smaller group does not believe that this dirtiness detracts from Portland’s beauty. On the contrary, these individuals value the “grittiness” they find in parts of Portland (such as NE Alberta St., downtown, and Inner Southeast Portland), contrasting this to the “over-sanitized” suburbs. This smaller group feels that Portland’s “rough edges” give it character and add to its beauty, rather than detracting from it. As the city grows and revitalizes, they do not want to see these rough edges disappear completely:

“[In 2030] it is very metropolitan with beautiful big buildings like the ones going in the Pearl District, but it still has a Portland feel. You know, farmers markets, cool old brick buildings, and neat old architecture, lots of greenery, the bums that make Portland, Portland, the street kids in Pioneer Square safe where we can keep an eye on them and secure in their only little spot…”